It's the other way around.

[He gets what he means, though. If 'he' is more comfortable than 'you,' then that's fine.]

I hated whoever it was who was doing the killing. You saw - he expected Taako and I planned to hurt him, right?

But when I found out it was y - [wait] . . .him, a lot of other things slotted into place, too. The other one of the Reapers was also this girl, Undine, who I liked a lot.

I just knew if that's who'd been doing it, there was more going on than I realized.